What happens when an entire generation shrinks? Right now in France, the answer seems to be “political chaos.” The country is grappling with the economic reality of shrinking birth rates—a challenge many experts predicted would hit decades from now. Instead, it’s arrived early in Western Europe’s heartland.
France’s Shrinking Birth Rates and Why It Matters
France has always been proud of its social safety net—a system built on the assumption that today’s workers pay for yesterday’s retirees. But what happens when there aren’t enough young people entering the workforce to support this model? Since 2024 alone, five different Prime Ministers have come and gone. Each found themselves stuck between ballooning state debts (thanks to welfare entitlements) and an electorate unwilling to accept higher taxes or reduced benefits.
The root issue? A rapidly ageing population combined with declining births. Without enough new taxpayers being born—and with older generations living longer—the math no longer adds up. Interest payments are spiraling out of control. And while the IMF and other major institutions have warned about this demographic time bomb for years, few expected it would cause government collapses this soon.
The Demographic Domino Effect Across Developed Countries
It isn’t just France feeling the heat. Other developed nations—think the US, Japan, and Britain—are watching closely because they’re not far behind. Ageing populations are putting unprecedented pressure on pension funds and public healthcare systems. Simply put:
- More people are retiring than joining the workforce.
- Fewer births mean fewer future taxpayers to fund pensions.
- Debt levels rise as governments borrow to maintain current benefits.
- Political gridlock makes reform nearly impossible.
- The old solutions—like mass immigration—are hitting social and political limits.
You can see similar patterns in countries like Japan (where adult diapers outsell baby diapers) or Italy (whose population is set to shrink by millions over coming decades). For more background on demographic challenges in Europe, see this summary from Brookings.
Is a Modern Debt Jubilee Really on the Table?
With traditional fixes running out of steam, some economists are dusting off an ancient solution—a Debt Jubilee. This isn’t a new idea; ancient societies like Babylon occasionally wiped away debts every few decades to reset their economies and prevent social unrest.
A modern Debt Jubilee would mean governments or central banks canceling certain classes of public or private debt to reset national balance sheets. It sounds radical but has been debated seriously by thinkers like Steve Keen (see his argument for “debt forgiveness” at SteveKeen.com). Supporters argue it could break the cycle of ever-rising interest payments that cripple countries with ageing populations.
But there are big questions:
- Who decides which debts get canceled?
- Would creditors accept such losses without causing market chaos?
- Could it undermine trust in currencies or banking systems?
A Real-World Glimpse: When Policy Hits Reality
A friend working at a Paris-based pension fund shared how their office atmosphere has changed over just two years. Once focused on growth investments for future generations, teams now scramble every week just to patch budget holes caused by surging retiree payouts—and fewer contributions from young workers entering their first jobs.
It isn’t just numbers on spreadsheets anymore; it’s real people making impossible choices daily as they try to keep promises made decades ago.
The Road Ahead—Can We Imagine Something Beyond Cuts or Taxes?
France may be the first major economy facing full-blown crisis from shrinking birth rates—but it won’t be the last. If nothing changes, other developed nations could soon face similar turmoil as their populations age and debts mount.
Could reviving something as dramatic as a Debt Jubilee really work today? Or will voters and politicians finally find ways to adapt welfare states without economic collapse? The debate is only beginning—and whatever happens next in France may set the tone for countries across the globe.
Are we ready to rethink our idea of debt—or will we simply keep passing the bill along until someone else can’t pay anymore?
Leave a Reply